ORDER DESSERTS FOR LOCAL PICK UP
Order
+
Products
+
Hours & Locations
+
About Us
+
ORDER ASAP
ORDER
Advanced Order for Local Pick Up
Same Day Pick Up or Delivery
Nationwide Shipping
Corporate Catering
Gifting & Events
VIEW ALL
Same Day Local Delivery & Pick Up
Advanced Order for Pick Up
Catering, Gifting & Events
NEW YORK
Bleecker Street
Bloomingdales
Central Park South
Grand Central Terminal
Grand Central Madison
Hudson Yards
LaGuardia Airport Terminal C
Moynihan Train Hall
Rockefeller Center
Upper West Side
CALIFORNIA
Los Angeles (West Hollywood)
ILLINOIS
Chicago (Loop)
INTERNATIONAL
India
Jordan
Kuwait
Philippines
Qatar
Türkiye
UAE
ABOUT US
Our Story
Careers
Newsroom
CONTACT US
HELP CENTER
SHOP BAKERY PRODUCTS
Fresh Banana Pudding
Brownies & Bars
Cakes
Cheesecakes
Cookies
Cupcakes
Icebox Desserts
In-Store Gift Cards
Online Only Gift Cards
 
Merchandise
Pudding of the Month
Pudding Club Subscription
Sampler Packs
Birthdays 🎂
Mother's Day Treats 💐
Graduation Gifts 🎓
VIEW GROCERY PRODUCTS
Banana Pudding
Banana Pudding Cookies
DoorDash Exclusive Banana Pudding
Store Locator
 Inspired by the nostalgic fluffernutter sandwich, the Puff’rnutter cupcakes feature a vanilla and chocolate cupcake topped with a luscious peanut butter buttercream frosting and filled with a gooey marshmallow center.
New! Gopuff Exclusive Puff’rnutter Cupcake
Mother's Day Treats
New! Frozen-To-Thaw Banana Pudding
Shopping Cart
YOUR CART
Shipping & Taxes calculated at checkout
YOUR CART
Shipping & Taxes calculated at checkout
Your cart is currently empty.

Welcome!

It looks like you're located in:

Would you like to visit instead?

Yes, take me there!
No, I'll stay here
Back

Sorry, you cannot add this item.

You cannot mix national and local delivery items in your cart. Please view your cart to make changes.

View Cart

Sorry, you cannot add this item.

You cannot mix subscription and one-time items in your cart. Please view your cart to make changes.

View Cart

Choose a local Magnolia Bakery to fulfill your order pickup

View All Locations

Please select an inscription color

To fulfill your request for a custom inscription we will require you to select an inscription color.

Select Color

Sorry, you cannot add this item.

You can only purchase 1 subscription at a time. Please remove the subscription from your cart if you'd like to choose a different subscription option.

View Cart

Is this a gift?

Magnolia Bakery Rewards | Terms and Conditions

Only purchases made in-store at Magnolia Bakery US locations are eligible for the loyalty program. Nationwide shipping orders, catering orders, or orders placed on third party delivery services are not eligible for the loyalty program. 

Customers who sign up for Magnolia Bakery’s loyalty program will earn 1 point per $1 dollar spent. Once a customer has spent $100, they will earn a $5 reward towards their next purchase. Members will earn 20 points when signing up, double points during specific promotional periods determined by Magnolia Bakery, and double points when ordering via Toast Online Ordering platform. 

Toast provides technology services that enable Magnolia Bakery to offer loyalty and/or rewards programs to Guests. By enrolling in any loyalty program offered by Toast or by Magnolia Bakery using Toast’s technology services, you expressly agree to these program terms. 

You may enroll in Magnolia Bakery’s loyalty program by signing up at Magnolia Bakery or while placing an order, subject to the Magnolia Bakery’s terms and conditions related to its loyalty program. Toast does not control Magnolia Bakery’s terms and conditions related to its loyalty program. Once you have enrolled, you may earn points when you make Purchases from Magnolia Bakery, which can later be redeemed for discounts or other benefits. If you initiate a return, chargeback, or refund, points associated with the Purchase may be revoked. You may check your current rewards balance by clicking the link you receive when you sign up for Magnolia Bakery’s loyalty program or through Magnolia Bakery’s online loyalty lookup page. When you enroll in Magnolia Bakery’s Loyalty program your payment card information may be linked to your Loyalty account. If you pay with a different payment card number and identify yourself as a loyalty member with Magnolia Bakery, the additional payment card number may be associated with your loyalty account in the future. You can remove linked payment cards by clicking the link you receive when you sign up for Magnolia Bakery's loyalty program or through Magnolia Bakery's online loyalty lookup page. 

If you choose to enroll in Magnolia Bakery's loyalty program, you agree that Magnolia Bakery may contact you using the contact method(s) you provide with program information, offers, and other marketing and transactional communications. Any information shared by Toast with Merchants is subject to our Privacy Statement. Once Magnolia Bakery has received information you provide from Toast, the use and governance of that information will be managed by Magnolia Bakery, which may have separate privacy practices and policies. Magnolia Bakery may not send marketing messages to your mobile number unless you expressly authorize Magnolia Bakery to send you such messages. 

Magnolia Bakery is solely responsible for the operation and maintenance of its own loyalty program, including establishing the number of points that you may earn when you make Purchases, setting redemption thresholds, and determining how and when points may be redeemed for rewards. Magnolia Bakery has the ability to modify the loyalty programs and/or to modify the points balance held by any individual Guest. Toast is not responsible for notifying you in the event that Magnolia Bakery changes any element of its loyalty program or ceases to offer a loyalty program. Magnolia Bakery is solely responsible for communicating program or points balance changes to you. 

Points earned through any loyalty program offered by Toast or Magnolia Bakery using Toast have no cash value and cannot be transferred, redeemed, or sold for cash. Loyalty programs may be based on spend, visit or transaction frequency, or any other manners of engagement, in Magnolia Bakery's discretion. Subject to notice requirements under Applicable Law and Rules, Toast reserves the right, in its sole discretion and at any time, to modify, suspend, terminate, revalue or cancel its own loyalty program and/or the technology services that enables Magnolia Bakery to offer loyalty programs through Toast. In the event Toast terminates any loyalty program offered by Toast or by Magnolia Bakery, Toast will, in accordance with the Applicable Law and Rules, maintain records of Guest’s loyalty points for one year following termination of the loyalty program in the event the loyalty program is reinstated within one year of termination. Toast reserves the right to adjudicate any discrepancies or disputes regarding rewards allocations or these program terms in its sole discretion and you agree to abide by any such adjudication. 

Magnolia Bakery Rewards | Terms and Conditions

Only purchases made in-store at Magnolia Bakery US locations are eligible for the loyalty program. Nationwide shipping orders, catering orders, or orders placed on third party delivery services are not eligible for the loyalty program. 

 

 

Customers who sign up for Magnolia Bakery’s loyalty program will earn 1 point per $1 dollar spent. Once a customer has spent $100, they will earn a $5 reward towards their next purchase. Members will earn 20 points when signing up, double points during specific promotional periods determined by Magnolia Bakery, and double points when ordering via Toast Online Ordering platform. 

 

 

Toast provides technology services that enable Magnolia Bakery to offer loyalty and/or rewards programs to Guests. By enrolling in any loyalty program offered by Toast or by Magnolia Bakery using Toast’s technology services, you expressly agree to these program terms. 

 

 

You may enroll in Magnolia Bakery’s loyalty program by signing up at Magnolia Bakery or while placing an order, subject to the Magnolia Bakery’s terms and conditions related to its loyalty program. Toast does not control Magnolia Bakery’s terms and conditions related to its loyalty program. Once you have enrolled, you may earn points when you make Purchases from Magnolia Bakery, which can later be redeemed for discounts or other benefits. If you initiate a return, chargeback, or refund, points associated with the Purchase may be revoked. You may check your current rewards balance by clicking the link you receive when you sign up for Magnolia Bakery’s loyalty program or through Magnolia Bakery’s online loyalty lookup page. When you enroll in Magnolia Bakery’s Loyalty program your payment card information may be linked to your Loyalty account. If you pay with a different payment card number and identify yourself as a loyalty member with Magnolia Bakery, the additional payment card number may be associated with your loyalty account in the future. You can remove linked payment cards by clicking the link you receive when you sign up for Magnolia Bakery's loyalty program or through Magnolia Bakery's online loyalty lookup page. 

 

 

If you choose to enroll in Magnolia Bakery's loyalty program, you agree that Magnolia Bakery may contact you using the contact method(s) you provide with program information, offers, and other marketing and transactional communications. Any information shared by Toast with Merchants is subject to our Privacy Statement. Once Magnolia Bakery has received information you provide from Toast, the use and governance of that information will be managed by Magnolia Bakery, which may have separate privacy practices and policies. Magnolia Bakery may not send marketing messages to your mobile number unless you expressly authorize Magnolia Bakery to send you such messages. 

 

 

Magnolia Bakery is solely responsible for the operation and maintenance of its own loyalty program, including establishing the number of points that you may earn when you make Purchases, setting redemption thresholds, and determining how and when points may be redeemed for rewards. Magnolia Bakery has the ability to modify the loyalty programs and/or to modify the points balance held by any individual Guest. Toast is not responsible for notifying you in the event that Magnolia Bakery changes any element of its loyalty program or ceases to offer a loyalty program. Magnolia Bakery is solely responsible for communicating program or points balance changes to you. 

 

 

Points earned through any loyalty program offered by Toast or Magnolia Bakery using Toast have no cash value and cannot be transferred, redeemed, or sold for cash. Loyalty programs may be based on spend, visit or transaction frequency, or any other manners of engagement, in Magnolia Bakery's discretion. Subject to notice requirements under Applicable Law and Rules, Toast reserves the right, in its sole discretion and at any time, to modify, suspend, terminate, revalue or cancel its own loyalty program and/or the technology services that enables Magnolia Bakery to offer loyalty programs through Toast. In the event Toast terminates any loyalty program offered by Toast or by Magnolia Bakery, Toast will, in accordance with the Applicable Law and Rules, maintain records of Guest’s loyalty points for one year following termination of the loyalty program in the event the loyalty program is reinstated within one year of termination. Toast reserves the right to adjudicate any discrepancies or disputes regarding rewards allocations or these program terms in its sole discretion and you agree to abide by any such adjudication. 

Contact Us

Contact Us

Join our Newsletter

Get the freshest Magnolia Bakery updates and offers right to your inbox! Plus, enjoy 10% off on your birthday when you share the date with us!

Join our Newsletter

Get the freshest Magnolia Bakery updates and offers right to your inbox! Plus, enjoy 10% off on your birthday when you share the date with us!

  • CAREERS
  • PRESS
  • INTERNATIONAL FRANCHISE
  • GIFT CARDS
  • SUBSCRIPTION
  • GIVING BACK
  • HELP CENTER
  • REFUNDS & RETURNS
  • LOYALTY REWARDS PROGRAM
  • LOYALTY REWARDS PROGRAM TERMS
  • WHOLESALE
  • NEWSROOM
  • ENTER OUR BAKE SALE

Have a question?

We're always here to lend a helping hand.

Consumer Care Team hours are Monday-Friday, 9am - 5pm EST

CONTACT US


  • Do Not Sell My Information
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Accessibility Statement
  • CAREERS
  • PRESS
  • INTERNATIONAL FRANCHISE
  • GIFT CARDS
  • SUBSCRIPTION
  • GIVING BACK
  • HELP CENTER
  • REFUNDS & RETURNS
  • LOYALTY REWARDS PROGRAM
  • LOYALTY REWARDS PROGRAM TERMS
  • WHOLESALE
  • NEWSROOM
  • ENTER OUR BAKE SALE

Have a question?

We're always here to lend a helping hand.

Consumer Care Team hours are Monday-Friday, 9am - 5pm EST

CONTACT US


  • Do Not Sell My Information
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Accessibility Statement
  • An order or experience at a Bakery
  • A nationwide shipping order placed online at magnoliabakery.com
  • An advance order for pick up placed online at magnoliabakery.com
  • A product purchased at a grocery store or online grocery
  • An order placed via third-party delivery apps (DoorDash, UberEats, Grubhub, etc)
  • Corporate Gifts
  • Catering and Events
  • Donation Request
  • Press or Partnership Inquiry
  • Help placing an order
  • Wholesale / Distribution
  • Other
ORDER ONLINE